Browse Episodes

The Disappearance of Cassidy Rainwater

To an outsider, it might seem like there isn’t a lot going on in Lebanon, Missouri. There is a Route 66 museum, a Walmart, a bowling alley, and a few shops. It’s less than 15 square miles and has about 14,000 residents. But if current trends hold, there’s a 1 in 19 chance that you will be a victim of a violent crime, making it one of the most violent areas in the United States. Because of its violent past and proximity to the Ozarks–an area with a surprising amount of unsolved missing person’s cases–Cassidy Rainwater’s mysterious disappearance garnered media attention. cases–Cassidy Rainwater’s mysterious disappearance garnered media attention.

The Disappearance of Kandi Green Gonzalez

In well publicized missing persons cases, the police usually make it a point to let the public know that they are tirelessly working on bringing the victim home and bringing the perpetrator to justice. And that’s their job, no matter the circumstances, which is why it is so upsetting when it feels like they’re doing the exact opposite. After Kandi Green Gonzalez disappeared, it seems as if the very people who are supposed to be helping find the missing 36 year old from Kentucky were the ones slowing the investigation down. In the months since Kandi was thrown out of her home that she shared with the former Sheriff’s son, her family has met nothing but deadends and have conducted much of the investigation on their own. Are the police really doing all they can to find Kandi or is there more to this story than they are letting on?

The Missing Case of Sydney Sutherland

Many young women often feel like there is nowhere safe in the world, and today’s case is a good example of why they might feel that way. What should have been a quick, relaxing run suddenly became deadly for Sydney Sutherland. A life can be altered in an instant and too often it’s the actions of men toward women which are the deadly triggers.

The Disappearance of Gabby Petito

If you’ve turned on the news at all this month, then we’re sure almost all of you have heard about this case. It’s been everywhere for the last few weeks. Beyond people’s interest in the mystery behind the case itself, the disappearance and death of Gabby Petito has brought up important conversations about unseen domestic abuse, which cases get prioritized in the media, and how regular people can make the biggest difference when solving cases. We’ll try to give you as much of the backstory about what is known in this case, but at this point, it’s still unfolding.

The Murdaugh Family Murders

After reading, or listening, to enough true crime, you might find the cases become somewhat formulaic. A person goes missing, a search party is sent out, a body is found, an arrest is ma de. Our case this week, though, is anything but that. Instead of inching closer to a solution, each new update only seems to generate more controversy and mystery around the Murdaugh Family.

Tyler Hadley – A Killer Party

Everyone has a crazy party story. But I bet that anyone who attended Tyler Hadley’s house party in Port St. Lucie, Florida on the night of July 16, 2011 can give you a run for your money. When Tyler posted on Facebook that he was having a party, over a 100 people came to his parents’ house to drink, do drugs, and party. What they didn’t know was that only hours before, Tyler had brutally murdered his parents. With their bodies hidden in the master bedroom, kids unknowingly partied in the bloody crime scene.

The Jacob Wetterling Abduction

In 1989, there were about 20,000 murders, but only 12,000 were solved. That’s only a 60% success rate, and that number hasn’t changed much in the last thirty years. You would think that with technology like DNA analysis and surveillance in more places, we’d be doing better. And of those unsolved crimes, few are solved years later. One of those 8000 unsolved cases in 1989 was the disappearance of Jacob Wetterling. Unlike so many others, this cold case did get a resolution, but it wasn’t until 27 years later. As a warning, this case references sexual abuse of children.

The Murder of Emily Noble

On the day after her 52nd birthday, Emily Noble’s husband, Matheau Moore, called the police to report that his wife had gone missing. For months, Emily’s friends and family searched high and low for her in her hometown of Westerville, Ohio. But when her body was suddenly found, months after her disappearance, hanging in a tree just behind her home, all eyes quickly turned to her husband. As a warning, this episode contains description of a staged suicide and other frequent mentions of suicide.